Anal pies, multi pies, sloppy seconds: Creampie Cathy offers a smorgasbord of cum-gooing holes for fans of hardcore amateur sex. Most often starring the sex-loving Cathy, famed amateur star, the site has more than 300 videos and galleries to offer members plus even more porn from Cathy's other sites and sex projects.
Enter Creampie Cathy →
  • Content Quality: 18.0 / 20
  • Quantity/Volume: 17.0 / 20
  • Updates Frequency: 15.0 / 20
  • Value for Money: 16.0 / 20
  • Reviewer Opinion: 15.0 / 20
81/100
Creampie CathyCreampie Cathy

Creampie Cathy Site Facts

  • Pictures
  • 333 Galleries
  • High Resolution: Yes
  • ZIP Files: Yes
  • No Watermarks: Yes
  • Videos
  • 333 Galleries
  • 1024x576 pixels Windows 3000 Kbps (downloadable)
  • 1024x576 pixels Quicktime 3000 Kbps (downloadable)
  • 640x480 pixels MPEG4 1800 Kbps (downloadable)
  • Full Scenes: Yes
  • Multi-Bandwidth: Yes
  • DRM: No
  • Exclusive
  • Content is semi-exclusive
  • Updates
  • No info
  • Cost
  • Monthly: $24.95 30 days, recurs at $19,95/mo.
  • Monthly: $24.95 30 days (non-recurring)
  • Multi-Mo: $44.95 90 days (non-recurring)
  • Billing
  • CCBill
  • Credit Card 900 #, Online Check

Creampie Cathy Review

Cathy and her husband have been together since they were teenagers, and even back then they were experimenting with threesome sex, sharing Cathy's holes and breasts with other friends both male and female. As they grew up together their sexual relationship changed and deepened, too. They started swinging; they started trying interracial sex and mini gang bangs; creampies, cock gagging, anal sex came next. After a few years break from swinging to raise their family, they roared back into the lifestyle with gusto, then a little thing called the internet became a sensation. With a cam corder and SLR camera, they set about creating one of the first homemade, hardcore amateur sex sites online.

One of those sites was Creampie Cathy. This is one of their later projects actually, not launching until 2003. The site is divided into a few sections: single load, double take, multi pies, sloppy 2nds, anal pies, clean up, and xtras. If you are unsure of what something means, they tell you: Sloppy seconds is when a woman is penetrated by a second male AFTER she has already been filled with another man's cum, for example. Hence the quite literal sloppy pussy seconds.

The videos in the library can be downloaded in near HD quality Windows Media and QuickTime formats. They have an excellent quality playback. You will also find DVD quality MPEG downloads. Running times bounce around a bit but most movies are a good length (5-10+ minutes long). Each scene comes with the video as well as the picture gallery. These contain an average of 20 or fewer photographs. They are high resolution and look great - expect some very graphic closeups. You can browse the set in a slideshow or download it in a zip file. The scenes at Creampie Cathy aren't dated so I was unable to determine how often they update.

When you first login you start at Cathy's member's lounge. This is the headquarters for all of her sites and from here you can access not only Creampie Cathy but all of her other sites like Cathy Does Blacks, Gang Bang Cathy and others.

Conclusion: 81/100
Creampie Cathy has some of the best homemade, truly amateur creampie porn that I've come across online. I really liked the couples adventurous spirit and how they do more then just single vaginal load cream pies, but sloppy seconds, multiple creampies, anal creampies and any other pie-type activity that occurs to them. With a big library and lots of other extras from Cathy the site is a great pick.

Network Bonus sites (4)

Creampie Cathy Adult Review
81 Creampie Cathy
Gang Bang Cathy Adult Review
75 Gang Bang Cathy
Cathy Does Blacks Adult Review
75.5 Cathy Does Blacks
Cathy's Craving Adult Review
80.5 Cathy's Craving